“I think it’s so great that you adopted them.” – Another “please don’t say that!”
Posted by KimAug 31
A while back I mentioned a particularly pushy check-out clerk who felt free to probe about exactly why my kids don’t look like me. I hit another one of those cringe-comments at church this weekend. From a great person, one who’s known me since I was a little girl, one who meant to be encouraging me, no doubt.
“I think it’s so great that you adopted them.” ["THEM," meanwhile, are standing right next to me.]
And as I’m thinking “Oh, no! Shh!” she continues about how great it is that Fred and I have brought the boys here and are “giving them such a great chance in life that they didn’t have before. And that you really love them like your own.”
And while my brain was firing red flags every which way, my mouth just wouldn’t work.
However, I plan to be ready with a reply next time because…
A) They aren’t LIKE our own… they ARE our own.
B) Anyone who knows our kids knows they’re usually like this freakish conglomerate of well-behavedness… They are some of the easiest kids to parent I’ve ever heard of. Plus they’re smart, funny, sweet with little kids and babies, affectionate, and full of joy and excitement … so no, there’s nothing amazing about what Fred and I are doing at all! Or have done. We wanted to adopt kids. And we did. So we’re just living from that point forward. And quite blessed in that life, I might add!
C) We don’t really know what their life would have been like, had they been able to remain with their first mom. Yes, it might’ve been really hard. On the other hand, God sure seems to love them and watch out for their protection (and I don’t mean “by having us adopt them,” I mean in every-day life things). So maybe they’d be doing just fine there. We don’t know. So let’s not speculate. And certainly not while they’re right there because…
D) We don’t want them to feel like we’re heroes who swooped in and rescued them. Or to think that we want them to think that. We followed what we believed was God’s call on our hearts to adopt. Now that we’ve taken on the responsibility of parenting them, shouldn’t we be doing our best, just like every other parent should be? Adoptive parent and bio-parent alike?
I fear that behind the “compliments” lies an undercurrent of belief that somehow what Fred and I and other adoptive parents have is second-best. A “Plan B” that falls after trying to have biological children. A rebound after disappointment. [I hope - perhaps naively? - that it's not because they're Latino.] I’m sure people assume that we adopted the twins because of infertility. We didn’t. We meant to adopt. Adoption is in both our families.
We’re just also ridiculously fortunate that our kids came to trust us and love us back so quickly, considering how many reasons they had to be guarded.
… What I would’ve said.
Next time. Just wait.
7 comments
Comment by Mary@notbefore7 on August 31, 2010 at 8:04 pm
CAn I be your next time so I can hear the rant in person…or can I at least be a fly on the wall
I love you lady – you rock! You tell ‘em momma!!!
Comment by Kim on August 31, 2010 at 9:06 pm
Oh, I fear I may become the face of “the adoptive mom you never want to meet”
Comment by Becky on September 1, 2010 at 7:05 am
You are so insightfully (is that a real word?) fresh on adoption and the issues that society pushes our way.
Our children are blessings from God and all in all He is guiding us on a path that reflects His plan for His children. People tend to think that because we have adopted that it is wonderful for us to love the unloveable, care for the uncared, and generally be the maintainance of the unwanted kids of the world. My God put His plan in my heart and Stephen’s before we even married. It was a topic that came up often about how we wanted to adopt. My children are God’s way of saying “I have made it so that you are the keepers of my treasures until I call them home”. I am amazed that he choose me for these children.
Comment by Amy on September 2, 2010 at 7:32 am
Kim and Becky,
What a sweet and protective way of looking at this issue. I do wish adoption wasn’t something that people needed continually explained to them. If you present children to others as you own it would be nice if there was no further discussion necessary. I think of our own brother who doesn’t really “match” the rest of our family, and the continued akwardness for him when people talk about him with our parents like he can’t hear them, and expect full explanation on who exactly he is, and why he looks different. I hope that in future years due to the commonness of adoption, divorce and re-marriage, and blended families, that people who are not close friends would stop asking deeply personal questions like that, and feeling the need to comment on any children in a family that “stand out” from the rest. I’m sure it makes adopted kids feel outside the norm when they hear the issues brought up again and again, and the feelings of the children should be top priority. Older people forget that kids understand way more than they give them credit for.
I don’t think that people really have an ettiquette framework for this topic, and I think that it may take a few blunt parents like you Kim to gently and firmly put people in their place for the sake of your kids feelings, and shut conversations down that go beyond “these are my adorable sons!” In the same way that the love of a spouse should be a permanent and unquestionable choice and delight, so should it be supposed of the kids in our families. There’s no need to constantly re-affirm your vows to your spouse every time you introduce them, and there’s no need to re-adopt your kids in front of anyone who questions you.
Comment by Colette on September 2, 2010 at 9:08 pm
LOL! You do rock! I want to hear it in person too!
Comment by Glenn on September 8, 2010 at 7:38 am
Gee Kim, I think it’s just so great that you adopted those poor little orphan boys. Were it not for you saving them, they would have surely been condemned to a life of foraging through garbage dumps! And look at you now — you love them as if they were your own kids! You are a hero and a savior and an all-around wonderful person! And I feel comfortable saying all this right in front of the kids, because I’m sure they can’t understand a word of English!
(Is that enough to set you off? Because I would really like to hear your rant!)
I’ve gotten the same thing every now and then, and I always turn it around: “Thanks, but really, WE are the lucky ones to have gotten such great kids.” Thus far, it’s done the trick. But it’s good to be armed with a more direct response, should it be required. So, thanks!
Comment by Kim on September 8, 2010 at 12:52 pm
Haha, yes I’d forgotten about that pet peeve: “Do they speak English yet?” No, they’ve only been here 3 1/2 years with English speaking parents, families, church, school, friends…. sigh.